Juan Fangio vs Giorgio Scarlatti

1957·

Juan Fangio and Giorgio Scarlatti shared only 4 races at Maserati in 1957; Juan Fangio led 4–0 on Sundays. Full grid and finish comparison.

These two shared only 4 races, so treat this as an indicative comparison rather than a settled one.

Juan FangioGiorgio Scarlatti

4Qualifying0

4 shared races

4Race day0

4 shared races

30Points1

in shared races, as awarded at the time

86Points (today’s rules)19

in shared races, rescored 25-18-15…

Wins: 2/0
Podiums: 4/0
Poles: 3/0
Retirements: 0/1
Best finish: P1/P5
Avg. grid: 1.8/12.3

Race by race

Round-by-round comparison of Juan Fangio and Giorgio Scarlatti
R	Grand Prix	Grid	Juan Fangio	Giorgio Scarlatti	Points
2	2Monaco Grand Prix	1/14	P1	Oil leak	9 / 0
6	6German Grand Prix	1/13	P1	P10	9 / 0
7	7Pescara Grand Prix	1/10	P2	P6	6 / 0
8	8Italian Grand Prix	4/12	P2	P5	6 / 1
	Average finish		P1.5	P7.0

How to read this table

The driver ahead in a round is shown in bold, the other in grey. Grid shows Juan Fangio / Giorgio Scarlatti.
P1 a win,P3 a podium,DNF a retirement.
▲ a finish at least 4 places better than that driver’s own average finish this season (see the average row), ▼ at least 4places worse. Retirements are not counted in the average.

Other Maserati battles in 1957

Other Maserati teammate battles in 1957
Matchup	Quali	Race	Points
Juan Fangio vs Harry Schell	7–0	7–0	46–10
Jean Behra vs Harry Schell	6–0	3–3	6–10
Jean Behra vs Juan Fangio	1–5	1–5	6–37
Giorgio Scarlatti vs Harry Schell	0–4	0–2	1–5
Carlos Menditeguy vs Harry Schell	2–2	1–3	4–5
Juan Fangio vs Carlos Menditeguy	4–0	4–0	25–4
Horace Gould vs Bruce Halford	1–2	1–2	0–0
Jean Behra vs Giorgio Scarlatti	3–0	1–2	0–1
Jean Behra vs Carlos Menditeguy	3–0	3–0	6–4
Paco Godia vs Bruce Halford	1–2	1–1	0–0
Paco Godia vs Horace Gould	1–2	3–0	0–0

Juan Fangio’s career Giorgio Scarlatti’s career Maserati 1957 season All teammate battles

How these numbers are calculated

Only races both drivers started are counted. Entries that did not qualify, did not pre-qualify or were withdrawn are excluded, as are cars that never left the grid or the garage, and the Indianapolis 500 of 1950–1960.
Until the mid-1960s drivers could share a car during a race. Each driver is compared from the car they started (which sets their grid position), with the best result of any car they drove and the points from all of them, as officially credited.
Qualifying is compared on grid position rather than session times. Session-by-session qualifying data only exists from 1994, while grid position is recorded for over 99% of entries right back to 1950 — including every race of the 1950s, 60s and 70s.
On race day the driver classified ahead takes the round. If neither was classified, the one who completed more laps is credited; if both retired on the same lap it is scored as a tie and excluded from the tally.
Points are those awarded at the time and include sprint races from 2021. Where the season used an older system, a second points row rescores every round under the current system so seasons from different eras can be compared.
These are points scored in the races both drivers started, not their season totals: races either missed, or contested alongside a different teammate, are left out. Up to 1990 even full-season totals differ from the championship standings, because only a driver’s best results counted towards the title. In 1988 Alain Prost outscored Ayrton Senna 105 to 94 and still lost the championship. Theseason page has the final standings.